In Depth Critiques Part 2!!!
So I made a forum thread like this many months ago and it was more of a success than I had anticipated. I had no idea ho many people were looking for really thoughtful critiques. So I thought that now that I have a bit of a break from work I should do it again.
So the rules are simple, Post one illustration and I will critique. The only exceptions I make are photography and abstract art, and literature or poetry. I will give a very well thought out critique to the best of my ability and knowledge.
I will try to get to everyone but I make no promises.
So the rules are simple, Post one illustration and I will critique. The only exceptions I make are photography and abstract art, and literature or poetry. I will give a very well thought out critique to the best of my ability and knowledge.
I will try to get to everyone but I make no promises.
Comments41
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
:origin()/pre01/f194/th/pre/f/2015/337/7/5/request___sinclaire_by_arasteia-d9iv6el.jpg)
:origin()/pre12/57b5/th/pre/i/2012/097/2/b/barefoot_battle_damaged_teen_piccolo_jr__by_dragonballfan2012-d4o42x9.jpg)
:origin()/pre00/374d/th/pre/i/2015/320/2/0/a_dark_hero_by_soulgeariis-d9gywfk.jpg)
Could you give critiques on this one?
![Harmony [Skf Contest Entry-Alam World] by fireytika](https://t02.deviantart.net/38Breq-PA6aeh3R9vTQTpPkgBxw=/300x200/filters:fixed_height(100,100):origin()/pre05/21de/th/pre/i/2015/317/8/a/harmony__skf_contest_entry_alam_world__by_fireytika-d9gh6ow.png)
:origin()/pre08/f180/th/pre/f/2015/181/3/d/greta_garbo_by_kentcharm-d8zdz1x.jpg)
:origin()/pre02/6521/th/pre/f/2015/202/7/0/michael_phelps__by_kentcharm-d92apde.jpg)
I hope you can understand roller coasters, they are my art.
:origin()/pre12/4047/th/pre/i/2015/303/c/c/neon_rider_by_gamespeaker13-d9evzsw.png)
"My XBOX Warrior"
:origin()/pre11/e95c/th/pre/i/2015/303/0/9/my__x_b_o_x__warrior_by_aliwithaneye-d9evoq9.jpg)
Hi,
can you please have a look on my painting sketches and give your valuable suggestions? My painting sketches is on my profile page my id is genieeesays
Thanks in advance
can you please have a look on my painting sketches and give your valuable suggestions? My painting sketches is on my profile page my id is genieeesays
Thanks in advance
:origin()/pre12/35bc/th/pre/i/2015/285/3/c/haloween_by_prime512-d9cuj0v.jpg)
:origin()/pre15/51a6/th/pre/i/2015/275/4/3/bima_x_by_prime512-d9bpciu.jpg)
:origin()/pre04/2b69/th/pre/i/2015/234/b/0/kuuga_cross_kiva_by_prime512-d96qj9a.jpg)
thanks for looking
Would mean a lot if you could critique my animation! I'm really trying to improve it <3
(click for full version. Has audio)
(click for full version. Has audio)
:origin()/pre08/a0f0/th/pre/i/2014/028/4/2/autistic_dreams_by_wislingsailsmen-d746swd.png)
would you critique this please? 
![[Contest Entry] Interdimensional crossroads by khkeyblademaster2](https://t06.deviantart.net/9J44-Uhpjhs3wr9dvByFBEB3VKo=/300x200/filters:fixed_height(100,100):origin()/pre05/52fa/th/pre/i/2015/288/e/1/_contest_entry__interdimensional_crossroads_by_khkeyblademaster2-d9d9535.png)
Commented, sorry for the delay
no problem, thanks man
:origin()/pre10/ad8f/th/pre/i/2015/288/6/4/ramen_by_tsukinopandaaa-d9d8uem.jpg)
Commented, sorry for the delay
Ah, I remember having asked you for a critique the last time you offered one.
If I'm allowed I'd like to do it again This time I should choose something other than a character design.
I think I try this one:
:origin()/pre00/264e/th/pre/f/2015/039/0/9/impetigo_by_florian_k-d8h6v84.png)
If I'm allowed I'd like to do it again
This time I should choose something other than a character design.I think I try this one:
Oh yeah i do remember critiquing you a while back. I really like this one btw 
Thank you very much
:origin()/pre11/185d/th/pre/f/2015/287/a/5/ranger_by_enemydesign-d9c50x2.jpg)
Commented