Nostalgia critic vs angry video game nerd


JJWsmith's avatar
Who do you think is better
Comments24
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
Redfoxbennington's avatar
AVGN is my main favorate until he turned into a faggy sellout. 

I like The Critic more. He understands good writing. 
concaholic's avatar
Nostalgia Critic.  
Didj's avatar
The Critic has really evolved over the years. He owns a small studio now and puts a lot of thematic effort into his productions. He even put together 3 episodic movies featuring the Critic and the online personas of his friends, each time becoming bigger in its production. The Nerd still films in his basement and James Rolfe rarely does AVGN episodes anymore. His one AVGN movie was nothing compared to any of the Critic movies. It's hard not to vote in favor of the Critic.
Badgercheese1994's avatar
I like both, but prefer NC.
HaraMesha's avatar
I don't know. I got into AVGN like around 2012. I watched his stuff around 2008-ish, and I didn't find it funny. I find his [older] stuff pretty good. Seems like a lot of people lost interest in for AVGN, ever since he brought in Mike Mattei and his movie. As for Nostalgia Critic, hes alright I guess. I saw Kickassia but I didn't really like it :/ Maybe cause i'm lame.....
Agent-Sarah's avatar
None, they both suck as the years got longer.
Taran13573794's avatar
AVGN's latest stuff has been atrociously awful; I watched his Seaman review a few days ago and was shocked by how unfunny it was. It's like he's lost sight of what made his character so funny to begin with: the rage factor. Without it, he simply can't get a laugh out of me.

So I guess I'll go with NC, but to be fair his newest stuff is really hit or miss and not nearly as funny as it used to be.
4-X-S's avatar
I don't watch those garbage.
Berlioz-II's avatar
I've watched only a couple of AVGN videos and never particularly got interested in his schtick (which is probably also since I'm not much of a gamer). So I guess I prefer the Critic considering I've watched much more of his stuff, though I've seriously grown out of his infantile sense of humour a long time ago and barely watch any of his videos anymore. Objectively speaking I have no idea which of them is truly "better."
manic-cure's avatar
The angry video nerd got old (and fatter) after a couple of videos.
Shawnlabomb's avatar
Yeah well, at least he's not bald! :iconmadnoesplz:
Agent-Sarah's avatar
And Channel Awesome is just dull as fuck and not even funny anymore (save for Brad from Cinema Snob, whose the ONLY person that's good).
manic-cure's avatar
Both had they're moments and it never really appealed after so long. I've never really watch the cinema snob.
Agent-Sarah's avatar
His reviews of the weirdest ass films and pornos I never heard of are classic.
manic-cure's avatar
Oh my :lol: in that case since I have free time I'll check him out!
Agent-Sarah's avatar
He does review other well known movies but those are wild. He has his own site up so have fun.
TheCunningCondor's avatar
I enjoy both but in my opinion, AVGN is getting tired. NC is still quite active.
Jarret91's avatar
Both of them are okay. I mean the angry reviewing gimmick has been done to death and it's just not interesting  to watch such a genre anymore. When it comes to their newer stuff I usually just passed due to lack of interest. 
JJWsmith's avatar
I like the nostalgia critic more plus I feel like the nerd ripped him off
Taran13573794's avatar
AVGN hit the scene long before the critic.