I think the scariest movie for me is Session 9. Nothing jumps out at you and there's no blood (I think there was a little blood at one point but I'm not sure) or ghosts, but it was scary for me because it was a more psychological scary. After I watched it, it really freaked me out
The Woman in Black really freaked me out. The ghosts were so agonizingly slow it just built up a lot of tension for me. That and I loved Sinister, but probably because I also loved Insidious lol Also can't turn down Paranormal. Those things give chills.
That's because they basically are XD All horror is the same just with a different twist or ending or both lol But what you think is scary changes what movies you'll like. Like me; I think someone watching you sleep is the creepiest shit on the plant. But you might think someone chasing you with a knife is the scariest. So without this turning into a psychiatric session, what kind of movies have you liked in the past? I'm vury curious.