Diablo 3 - Diablo 2 in new wrappings. They didn't even try to hide the obvious rip-offs.
Guild Wars 2 - A nice game but didn't live up to the hype at all. Way too many bugs, imbalances and the PvP format is boring as hell. Let's hope it gets better with time so I might actually consider making the Ranger I expected to play.
WoW: Mists of Pandaria - Fun at first and I expected a lot but turns out that this "PvP oriented expansion" completely wrecked said PvP. Arenas are a mess.
Mass Effect 3 - Awesome. The last 10 minutes could've been a million times better but at least the DLC fixed it up a little.
Witcher 2 EE - Awesome improvements to an awesome game.