I absolutely loved KOTOR 1 + 2. I completed the first one a couple of times and the 2nd one I lose count. I absolutely loved them. When I found TOR would be a PC only MMO I was skeptical.
The other week I got a new laptop for work and quickly set up TOR and jumped online. It seems 'OK' but unlike you I'm still waiting for the game to get good. It feels like the old KOTOR games which is to say it feels old fashioned. I spent a whole day on it, using the free to play option. All day I spent debating on whether it was worth subscribing or not. I figured it probably wasn't and since last monday (the day I started playing) I haven't put it on again.
I have a feeling this will be like The Matrix online for me. I tried it, put off playing it, then they closed the servers so I never got to finish it.
I will be watching this thread though it will be interesting to see what ppl are saying about it