Can you love on command?


Greatest-I-am's avatar

Can you love on command?

 

Matthew 22:36-40 (KJV)

36 Master, which is the great commandment in the law?

37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.

38 This is the first and great commandment.

39 And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.

40 On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.

 

----------------------------------------------

 

Jesus should know, --- if intelligent at all, that an emotions like love cannot be commanded or demanded from people.

 

Whatever force was driving Jesus to put that command into our reality, be that force or God real or myth, could not have been a very intelligent force.

 

You recognize those you love and who return the emotion by works and deeds.

 

Can one be effectively ordered to love knowing that true love, as with true faith, must have deeds, works and reciprocity?

 

Imagine you never doing anything for those you love. They would and could not know you love them. Imagine those who profess loving you without them ever showing it by actions. You could never know that they love you.

 

Can you love on command a God that is not here and unable to share that love?

 

Can you love your neighbor without doing something for him?

 

Is love a one way thing or must it be returned to be real love?

 

Are the so called great commandments unworkable rhetoric?

 

You should know that I think we are basically all living those commandments in a partial and blind way, as we are collectively helping our poorer neighbors. It is the intellectual efficacy or veracity of those commands that I question.

 

Regards

DL

Comments88
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
DelSolTormenta's avatar
Stockholm syndrome maybe
Greatest-I-am's avatar
That would do it.

Regards
DL
siegeonthorstadt's avatar
our feelings shape from our thoughts as our thoughts form selectively according to our feelings. think hard enough and you will trigger love. we dont have *that* much of a complicated brain really.
Greatest-I-am's avatar
One cannot trigger true love without reciprocity.

It, love, must be reflected back to be true love.

What you speak of is not love. 

Regards
DL 
siegeonthorstadt's avatar
comeon.. there is a thing called platonic love. favor exchange is something completely different.
Greatest-I-am's avatar
There is no love without reciprocity.

Look at your own relationships.

Regards
DL
ImperialNokhtis's avatar
Over thinking it-just a bit. but obviously no. But the point of faith is blind trust.
Greatest-I-am's avatar
Correct.

Faith vs Reason

 

Faith is a way for you to quit using your "God given" power of Reason and Logic, so you will believe doctrines that moral men reject as immoral.

 

The God of the OT says...“Come now, and let us reason together,” [Isaiah 1:18]

 

How can you reason with God when you throw away reason?

 

Religions, especially Christianity reply.

 

“Faith must trample under foot all reason, sense, and understanding.”

“Reason is a whore, the greatest enemy that faith has.”

Martin Luther “

 

This puts the rest of us in a position where reasoning with theist becomes impossible.

 

It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into.

Jonathan Swift

 

Literalism is an evil practice that hides the true messages of myths. You cannot show our friends that they are wrong through their faith colored glasses. Their faith also plugs their ears.

 

Regards

DL

Andrew-YM's avatar
Well, let's test it.
Love me! I demand love!
Did it work?
Greatest-I-am's avatar
You know the answer and we are on the same page. Nice.

Regards
DL
Dastyni's avatar
Greatest-I-am's avatar
www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsX5mr…

It is not true love without reciprocity and works.

Regards
DL
Dastyni's avatar
So shut your fingers up, and think more carefully before you offend me.
Gyzmo-Grim's avatar
Oh please, you're just a man behind a computer screen that's hundreds of miles away from me. I'm not afraid of you.
Dastyni's avatar
I am the entity that takes the place of your dissolved earth so that YOU can exist in comfort, not having to know that you and all the inhabitant of the earth are fucking dead.
Gyzmo-Grim's avatar
Doesn't god have a thing about swearing?
Dastyni's avatar
Listen, 'woman' this is my fucking planet. Shit goes down HOW I fucking say it does.


DO YOU FUCKING UNDERSTAND?
Gyzmo-Grim's avatar
Do you honestly think I'm afraid of you? You're in Canada. I'm in the US. I do not have to listen to you. Also, saying that it is your planet implies that you are somehow god or godlike.

Actually, you are not the boss of me. I dare you to try to get a girlfriend using the language and saying the things you have said to me. You will probably not have very much luck.
Dastyni's avatar
Pansexual is alright if you are not of this earth.
Gyzmo-Grim's avatar
So you're saying I'm an angel? Thank you!
Dastyni's avatar
I will preach to you, animal, but you must stop trying to judge God.


You are not meant to judge God.
Greatest-I-am's avatar
He tells us to do just that.

How else could you know how great he is? Or not?

Regards
DL
Gyzmo-Grim's avatar
Don't listen to that guy; he pretty much told me that my being pansexual was an abomination because I, as a woman, was created to serve men like him.
Greatest-I-am's avatar
Ouch.

Idiocy is rampant.

Fight it when you can.

Regards
DL