Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 
[x]  
Shop deviantART for the holidays Click here! :holly:
:iconhakubaikou:
I often run across artists making some comment along the lines of "a true artist is always his/her own worst critic" or "a real artist is never truly happy with his/her work". I read all the time about artists saying that they only see the flaws in what they do, and that they hate their own art.

I've never really understood that. I mean, I love my own art. I look at it, and I am almost always very happy with it. I actually get a lot of pleasure looking at it.

That's not to say I don't see flaws in it. Frankly, every single piece I've churned out has had plenty of flaws. Some more than others. But it doesn't stop me from enjoying my work. And it isn't enough to make me unhappy with it. There is no way I could ever be my own worst critic. Nor would I want to be, to be honest.

I can understand the sayings if they're talking about a desire to always be better, to always grow as an artist. That's something I do feel very strongly. But I don't necessarily equate a desire to improve with a dissatisfaction with or dislike of my work. Maybe it's a dissatisfaction with my current skill level, but even then, dissatisfaction implies a negativity that I don't think I feel. And it's definitely not a dissatisfaction with the art itself.

I guess I just don't understand why some people seem to feel the need to lump the two together. If you like your own works, then you're not a true artist? I feel like that's a terrible state to be in, especially considering the only reason I even do art is because I love it, and it brings me happiness. To always have that happiness dampened by some feeling of inadequacy is something I can't imagine.

So, am I missing something? I'm wondering how other people feel about this. Are you dissatisfied with your current skill level? And if so, does that affect how much you like or dislike your actual artwork? Do you think of the two things as the same? Or are they two different things to you? Do you agree that "an artist must be his own worst critic?"

--
"Nothing is written." --- LoA

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconfrankman:
Well, if I'm already satisfied with my own work, I wouldn't have the desire to make another one, since I already have one that fulfills me completely

--
Commission FAQ Here

Av by `Damaged927



FREE REQUESTS AVAILABLE HERE: [link]
:iconprince-charles:
I am not "satisfied" with my level of skill, but I can still be happy with things I make. Some of them, I do genuinely like looking at.

--
"Every time you eat waffles, your mind is living in sin" :tea:

How to Look Like an Ass in Your Signature.
:iconsludgee:
That's a good question.

I think the artist is the most important
critic, not necessarily the worst. If he/she doesn't like
their own work, why do it?

I'm often disatisfied with
my own "work," so the only
thing I can do to finish anything is to deem it
"good enough, I suppose."

Because, after all, our art won't
be perfect, no matter what we do.

--
I'm looking for the Soul Tomato!
:iconprince-charles:
For me, I don't create just so I can have a finished piece to look it - that is more a "side effect". I am often satisfied with finished pieces. But I do want to "get better" - and for me, the 'getting there' is more important than looking at what is done.

--
"Every time you eat waffles, your mind is living in sin" :tea:

How to Look Like an Ass in Your Signature.
:iconfrankman:
Well, seems like getting to a certain point means you haven't reached it yet with your latest skill, making you unsatisfied with what you see :)

--
Commission FAQ Here

Av by `Damaged927



FREE REQUESTS AVAILABLE HERE: [link]
:iconprince-charles:
I don't know, there's stuff from a year ago that, although I have surpassed it in skill, I still enjoy looking at it and am "happy" with it.

I can see how I improve with each and every piece, but it doesn't make me dislike what came before.

--
"Every time you eat waffles, your mind is living in sin" :tea:

How to Look Like an Ass in Your Signature.
:iconhakubaikou:
I don't know. Maybe it's just a question of semantics, but I really don't feel like a desire to improve or to do another piece necessarily means there's a dissatisfaction with the current piece.

I guess I would think of it like... If I had a delicious and utterly satisfying piece of chocolate cake. The experience is pleasurable, and I'd want it to happen again. I'd love another slice of cake someday, but it doesn't mean I was dissatisfied with the piece I just ate.

Ha, I have no idea if that made any sense. It's late, and I have a terrible headache at the moment. But that's the clearest way I could describe how I look at it, it at the moment.

--
"Nothing is written." --- LoA
:iconhakubaikou:
I'm generally happy with what I make too. More often than not, I enjoy looking at my art. Even the old stuff that has a ton of mistakes in it. I still like looking at those too, even though they're flawed like crazy.

--
"Nothing is written." --- LoA
:iconhakubaikou:
I like the idea of an artist being his most important critic. That sounds much more reasonable than worst critic.

No, our art definitely won't be perfect. I guess it just depends on how happy an artist can be with that imperfection.

--
"Nothing is written." --- LoA
:iconnk-chan:
I dunno... I used to always like my stuff a lot, like you said, but right now I'm always sorta underwhelmed with what's been coming out cuz I haven't been able to create the kinds of things I want. But I do like some parts of my stuff still so I think it's just a phase. So... maybe they're all just stuck in a phase that they've never been out of..?

Site Map